Lesson Plan October 16, 2019
The Weekly: Tracing Conflict Minerals from the Ground to the Consumer
State:
Grades:
Warm-up: Uncovering the role of gold in your everyday life.
Introducing the Resource: Watching “Apple's Gold,” an episode of "The Weekly." The full episode is available on The New York Times website here, though there may be a limit to how many episodes you can view or a subscription may be required. Some episodes are also available to subscribers on FX or Hulu.
Discussion: Exploring the content and structure of this episode.
In-class Activity: Evaluating the role of different entities in the Colombian gold trade.
Extension Activities:
1. Researching conflict resources and creating an explanatory video
2. Developing recommendations on responsible trade and consumerism
Objectives:
Students will be able to...
- Understand the reporting process for investigative journalism
- Trace the supply chain of natural resources, including conflict minerals
- Evaluate the role of different actors in illegal trade and its consequences
Warm-up:
What role does gold play in your everyday life? With a classmate, brainstorm a list of things you think gold might be used to make. Then, do some research. Are any of the things you found surprising to you? How many of them do you or your family use in your everyday life?
Introducing the Resource:
In this episode of "The Weekly," you will trace the journey of gold all the way from the ground to its distribution in common household electronics. Along the way, you will learn about how a journalist conducts an investigation into a company's supply chain, and how a simple question—where does the gold in my cell phone come from?—can lead to big stories about international trade, fair labor standards, drug trafficking, bribery, and murder.
While you watch "Apple's Gold," track how the journalists uncover the story and what evidence they provide for their claims by answering the following questions:
Click here for a printable PDF
Viewing guide for "Apple's Gold"
Discussion:
1. Casey says that "being a good corporate citizen has become a central part of the Apple brand.
- What does it mean to be a "good corporate citizen"?
- How is Apple failing to live up to that reputation?
2. Make a list of the people interviewed in "Apple's Gold" and their roles in the Colombian gold trade. Then, discuss:
- What purpose does each interview serve?
- Who declines to be interviewed by The New York Times, and why?
- If you were the journalist reporting this story, who else might you interview?
3. What impact had this reporting made by the time "Apple's Gold" aired? What problems remain?
In-class Activity:
Casey establishes an immediate connection between the Colombians featured in this story and U.S. viewers by telling us that the U.S. is the top buyer of Colombian gold.
1. Break into groups of approximately four students each. Each group will be assigned one of the following issues associated with the Colombian gold trade:
- Labor conditions
- Violence and extortion
- The environment
2. With your group, brainstorm and write down the following:
- A definition of the problem, as it relates to Colombian gold mining, citing evidence from "Apple's Gold"
- A list of entities who bear responsibility for the problem
- A list of recommendations for how to improve the situation, indicating the entity toward whom each recommendation is directed
3. Present your work to the class. While you listen to your classmates' presentations, take notes on which recommendations you think are most and least compelling.
4. Discuss them as a class:
- Which recommendations do you find most compelling, and why?
- Which recommendations do you find least compelling, and why?
- What can you do personally to act on these recommendations?
Extension Activities:
Option 1. Research create an explanatory video
1. Rewatch minutes 10:25–11:12 of "Apple's Gold," in which Nicholas Casey explains the gold supply chain. This is a concise explanation of a complex process, using simple narration and images to illustrate.
2. Learn about the supply chain of another resource in order to explain it to your classmates. Use one of these news stories to get you started:
- Cobalt: Blood, Sweat, and Batteries
- Palm oil: Climate Change and Human Trafficking in Indonesia
- Hair: How Women in Poverty Are Supplying America's Market for Hair
- Cotton: Our Cotton Colonies
- Sand: The World's Disappearing Sand
- Canned tomatoes: Are Your Tinned Tomatoes Picked by Slave Labor?
- Lead: The World's Most Toxic Town: The Terrible Legacy of Zambia's Lead Mines
- Ivory: With Elephant Ivory Banned, a Brisk and Worrying Trade in Mammoth Tusks
- Cocoa: Cocoa and Justice in Ivory Coast
3. Using evidence from one of the news stories above and at least two additional sources, create a video explaining the supply chain of the resource you chose, from its presence in nature to the hands of consumers. Using "Apple's Gold" as a model, illustrate your narration with images. Be sure to include a bibliography at the end of your video to credit the sources of information and images.
Option 2. Share your recommendations
1. Revisit the recommendations you and your classmates came up with during your in-class activity. Which ones are standing out to you?
2. Write a letter to your local representative that summarizes "Apple's Gold," explains how the Colombian gold trade connects to your community, and lays out the action steps you would like to see your representative take. Use this template to guide your writing.
3. Enter your letter into the Pulitzer Center's Local Letters for Global Change contest for the chance to be published and honored on the Pulitzer Center website and win a cash prize for your class. Find full contest details and the Google Form for entries at pulitzercenter.org/localletters, and email [email protected] with questions or for support.
4. Alternative: Base your letter and recommendations on any of the suggested readings listed in Option 1, or any other news stories found here.